Commercial Real Estate Appraisers in New Castle, PA
The top-ranked commercial appraisers serving New Castle, PA are Sara Gaskill, Kevin Mcilwain and Dan Paulus. We list 49 commercial appraisers serving New Castle, PA. 30 of the providers shown match an active record from MD appraiser board via ASC National Registry and NY appraiser board via ASC National Registry, checked on the date shown. Rankings follow our published methodology; sponsored placements never change rank.
Commercial Real Estate Appraisers serving New Castle, PA (Lawrence County). 49 providers, 10 of the top 10 verified against federal or state records. Registry records checked on 2026-11-04.
Top 10 ranked commercial appraisers for New Castle
- SARA M GASKILL REVIEW SERVICES, LLCServes this area from PAVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (MD), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (NY), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (OH), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (PA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (VA), ASC National Registry
#2Kevin Mcilwain
Serves this area from PA#3Dan Paulus
J.S.Held LLCServes this area from PAVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (AZ), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (CA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (FL), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (GA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (PA), ASC National Registry#4David Mcconahy
NICKLAS KING MCCONAHYServes this area from PAVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (GA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (IL), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (KY), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (MI), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (NC), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (OH), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (PA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (SC), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (TN), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (VA), ASC National RegistryVerified: State Certified General Appraiser (WV), ASC National Registry#5Kevin Scott
Vantell Associates, Inc.Serves this area from OH#6Gregory Vantell
Serves this area from OH#7Jason Vantell
Serves this area from OH#8Lisa Talmo
Serves this area from PA#9Daniel McCown
Dan McCown & Co, Inc.Serves this area from PA#10Edward Cline
Serves this area from PA
20 more providers serving this area
- John Ungham, PA
- Paul Chiappetta, PA
- Steven Brenner, PA
- Brian Beck, OH
- Richard Segesto, OH
- Sheree Nemenz, OH
- Thomas Coppola, Youngstown, OH (17 mi)
- Thomas D'Amico, OH
- Richard Hill, North Lima, OH (17 mi)
- Megan Hennessey, Mercer, PA (17 mi)
- James Grantz, Youngstown, OH (17 mi)
- David Gustas, Sharon, PA (18 mi)
- John Somora, PA
- Christopher Frederick, PA
- Timothy More, PA
- Edith Crawford, OH
- Bruce Lydic, PA
- John Paventi, Austintown, OH (23 mi)
- David Gustas, PA
- Connor King, PA
Request quotes
Frequently asked questions
How many commercial appraisers serve New Castle?
We list 49 commercial appraisers serving New Castle, PA: 0 based there and 49 serving it from nearby. 10 of the top 10 match an active federal or state record, checked on 2026-11-04.
Which commercial appraisers serve New Castle?
The top-ranked commercial appraisers serving New Castle, PA are Sara Gaskill, Kevin Mcilwain, Dan Paulus, David Mcconahy and Kevin Scott. The full ranked list, with the official records each provider matched, is on this page.
Which commercial appraisers serving New Castle are verified against official records?
10 of the top 10 match an active official record: Sara Gaskill (MD appraiser board via ASC National Registry; NY appraiser board via ASC National Registry; OH appraiser board via ASC National Registry; PA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; VA appraiser board via ASC National Registry), Kevin Mcilwain (MI appraiser board via ASC National Registry; OH appraiser board via ASC National Registry; PA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; VA appraiser board via ASC National Registry), Dan Paulus (AZ appraiser board via ASC National Registry; CA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; FL appraiser board via ASC National Registry; GA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; PA appraiser board via ASC National Registry), David Mcconahy (GA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; IL appraiser board via ASC National Registry; KY appraiser board via ASC National Registry; MI appraiser board via ASC National Registry; NC appraiser board via ASC National Registry; OH appraiser board via ASC National Registry; PA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; SC appraiser board via ASC National Registry; TN appraiser board via ASC National Registry; VA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; WV appraiser board via ASC National Registry) and Kevin Scott (OH appraiser board via ASC National Registry; PA appraiser board via ASC National Registry; WV appraiser board via ASC National Registry), and 5 more on this page. Each badge links to the official record it matched.
How are these companies ranked?
By our published methodology: verified registrations, documented capabilities, years registered and responsiveness. Sponsored placements are shown separately and never affect rank.
What does "Verified" mean on this page?
"Verified" means we matched the provider to an active official record on the date shown; each badge links to that record. The absence of a badge only means we have not verified that item.
Who can appraise commercial property?
Federally related commercial appraisals generally require a State Certified General appraiser. Every appraiser listed here holds an active Certified General credential in the ASC National Registry.
"Verified" means we matched the provider to an active official record on the date shown. The absence of a badge only means we have not verified that item. How we rank and verify. Page updated .